Alaine Locke's analysis of the New Negro is localized in Harlem and argues the explosion of Negro art and expression as the revolutionary indicator of the New Negro. He argues that the new shift into the self-expression of the Negro, about his internal world, signals a change in the Negro spirit that is proud, confident, and defiant. Locke suggests that "the elements of truest social portraiture...in the artistic self-expression of the Negro to-day [is] a new figure on the national canvas and a new force in the foreground of affairs"(Locke, xxv). Therefore, Locke defines the New Negro as the artist who exposes the internal reality of the their own mind and spirit, and take back a narrative about themselves that has so long been defined by the language and paradigms of white society.
While Locke defines the New Negro as the ground-breaking artists of Harlem, Baldwin defines the New Negro as the rising Black Entrepreneurs in Chicago, who are challenging the hegemonic structures of white society through the economic arena. Baldwin explores the success of Madam C.J. Walker, who established herself as a prominent staple in the beauty market. Madam C.J. Walker 'promoted herself ' from the cotton fields to the typically white, and typically male world of business. While she didn't experience the universal support of black leadership at the time, and the "old settlers" of Chicago, she established herself as a lucrative business woman making it on her own accord. Madam C.J Walker fundamentally shifted the paradigms of beauty culture and ignited the "emergence of black beauty not just as an enterprise but also as a vibrant intellectual discourse about about alternative expressions of New Negro womanhood"(Baldwin, 56). Baldwin describes Madam C.J. Walker and others who broke through the economic restraints of the "invisible hand" and single-handedly creating a new black middle class.
Although Locke and Baldwin differ on their specific definitions of the New Negro, both look to a population that is disrupting the racial hierarchy and hegemonic structures through their own means. This blatant assertion of agency in both the economic and artistic realms reveals a New Negro set on defining his reality beyond the narratives of white society. No longer does the "Negro" passively, adhere to the abuses and oppression of White society, rather he (she) finds new ways to challenge, destabilize, and disrupt the structures of white society that have inhibited the black community for too long.